Sunday, November 15, 2026

Review: The Only Good Indians

The Only Good Indians The Only Good Indians by Stephen Graham Jones
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

  This book is written in a unique voice.  I imagine it's hard to read page to page but the narrator of the Audiobook did a fantastic job bringing the characters, and their native accents, to life in a what that made the story easier to follow.  There were still moments when the descriptions of setting, scenery, and emotion were so thick and presise that they made my mind wander.  But I was gripped by the story from beginning to end. 

What I liked: The education.  This story felt fresh grown off the reservation and taught me alot about what Native People's go through.  I really appreciate a story from a perspective I'm not used to and learning about a culture as American as fry bread.  

What I loved:  The monster.  The descriptions of Elk Head Woman, the way she tracked her prey.  The way she leers, and stalks.  The way no one sees her coming until it's too late.   The tension.   I even appreciate the way it ends.
SPOILERS:

What I hated:  Basketball.  I understand WHY the Elk Head Woman played basketball to weaken, distract, and lore her victims, but I don't understand HOW an elk spirit monster is supposed to be so good at basketball - or that matter being a predator.   I also didn't like her motivation for hunting down and killing all these Native men.   I hate the countless tragedies that occur just because one of the hunters threw away a package of freezer burnt meat that was meant to feed an elder ten years later.  Besides Native American mythology high-jinx I don't understand why all those men deserved to die. Just never saw Elk as vindictive - but do I know, I'm a city dweller.  I've never even seen a live elk.  I think it's great when she still acts like an elk around trains but I don't even know if that's true about elk being scared of trains. 

There were a few places where the placement of people in the action didn't make since to me.  Why she under the truck?  We saw him dead in the outhouse, how is he walking now?  What happened to her mother?  So....he's the father of the monster that is killing his friends?   Mythology is wild.  
Overall I enjoyed this story for it's voice, premise, and dramatic jaw dropping horror.  If you're having trouble reading it page to page, the audiobook is a great alternative in this case.  


If you enjoyed this story you might also like the 










View all my reviews

No comments:

Post a Comment